Truth or Fiction?
Menu

Truth or Fiction?

Pray for 15 year old Amanda-Fiction!

Rich Buhler & Staff
Rich Buhler is the founder of TruthorFiction and was a broadcaster, speaker, author, broadcast journalist, and producer who researched and wrote about rumors and urban legends for more than 30 years. Because of both his knowledge about what he terms “eRumors” and his broadcast background, Rich was a popular guest on radio and television and has appeared on national and international outlets including on CNN, MSNBC, NBC, Fox News, BBC, CBC, as well as local television and radio stations from Maryland to California. He has also either written, or been featured in, numerous newspaper and magazine articles. Rich operated TruthOrFiction.com until his death from pancreatic cancer in May of 2012, his family wrote and operated truthorfiction.com on his behalf until late 2018 and are still owners of the site.

Pray for 15-year-old Amanda-Fiction!

Summary of eRumor:

This eRumor includes a message from a 15-year-old girl named Amanda and another message from her mother.

It says that Amanda is suffering from a mysterious degenerative medical condition and wants people to pray for her and let her know they are praying.

She says the Make-A-Wish Foundation is sending her and her family to Hawaii.
 
 

The Truth:


There are several things about the email that don't ring true.

It says that the girl has an "undiagnosed" condition. Anyone who has a girl with health issues as serious as described would probably not misuse the word "diagnosed."
If she's got a "neuromuscular degenerative disease," that's a diagnosis even though the cause of it or the prognosis may be uncertain.

The story avoids the kind of details that a mother would normally include in a narrative about a seriously ill child.

We checked with the Make-A-Wish Foundation and they said they didn't know anything about this story.

Last updated 3/11/04