Truth or Fiction?
Menu

Truth or Fiction?

Does This Picture Show a Tiny Crowd Ten Minutes Before Sen. Bernie Sanders' April 2019 Houston Rally?

Kim LaCapria
Kim LaCapria is a New York-based Content Manager, fact checker, and folklore enthusiast. She began debunking viral urban legends full-time in 2009, and in 2014 became the first editorial employee of Snopes.com, authoring thousands of political and viral fact checks. For several years, she worked to modernize the site and broaden its profile and scope. Those efforts came to fruition in 2016, leading to acclaim and global acknowledgement of the necessity for fact-checking and its role in slowing mis-and-disinformation on social media. Kim joined TruthOrFiction.com in December 2018. After work, she enjoys air hockey, water parks, jjimjilbangs, and internet culture.

On April 26 2019, Facebook page "The Trump Train" shared the following post (archived here), claiming that it showed a crowd of a few dozen people in Houston ten minutes before Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vermont) was scheduled to speak:

https://www.facebook.com/TheTrumpTrainExpress/photos/a.959587150743121/2174109532624204/?type=3&theater

Across the top of an image of a few dozen people, the text read:

4/24/19 - Bernie's Rally crowd in Houston, 10 minutes prior to him taking the stage....

Underneath the image, a screenshot of a Houston Public Media article ("Bernie Sanders Rally Draws Big Crowd In Houston") appeared underneath additional text added to the photograph:

This is what the Fake News media calls a "Big Crowd"

The meme makes a very specific claim — that the image was taken just ten minutes prior to Sanders' scheduled appearance. It also heavily implies that this was the entirety of the crowd there to greet him.

According to BernieSanders.com, the event began at 5 in the afternoon local time, and doors opened at 3:30, an hour and a half before the rally. On the day of the rally, the same photograph was shared to Reddit's r/The_Donald. However, at that point no one claimed that the image was "ten minutes" prior to the start of the rally. Three days later, a Twitter user posted the same image shared to Reddit, that time with the "ten minutes" claim included:

https://twitter.com/borderfox116/status/1122196761257357314

In fact, a number of people on social media pushed identical or extremely similar claims about the exact same image:

https://twitter.com/right4trump/status/1121213585504518144
https://twitter.com/LCohob/status/1121430389963333633
https://twitter.com/NJCommonSense/status/1121211587191296001

But a nearly identical photograph was shared to Twitter on the day of the rally. In that tweet, the poster said that the image was taken two hours before the rally, or 30 minutes before the stated "doors open" time:

https://twitter.com/travispainter17/status/1121196645310504960

The same person sent a second tweet with a screenshot of a television showing a larger crowd during the rally:

https://twitter.com/travispainter17/status/1121196786570399744

A similar photograph was timestamped at 4:30 local time, again prior to the start of the rally, contradicting the "ten minutes before" claim:

https://twitter.com/WilpowerRacing/status/1121180261377613824

Attendees of the rally also shared photographs of the crowd from the ground:

https://twitter.com/BrentSullivan/status/1121182459016691714
https://twitter.com/AriRabinHavt/status/1121190916201562113

The image of a Bernie Sanders rally in Houston seen in the meme was originally labeled as having been taken two hours prior to the event, not ten minutes before. A number of unlinked accounts began sharing the same photograph and claim, despite a mismatch with images of the event after doors opened at 3:30 PM local time. According to the Houston Chronicle's coverage of that event, about 3,000 people attended Sanders' rally in support of his 2020 election bid.