Truth or Fiction?
Menu

Truth or Fiction?

The Hunters who end up dynamiting a brand new SUV and their dog on a frozen lake-Fiction!

Rich Buhler & Staff
Rich Buhler is the founder of TruthorFiction and was a broadcaster, speaker, author, broadcast journalist, and producer who researched and wrote about rumors and urban legends for more than 30 years. Because of both his knowledge about what he terms “eRumors” and his broadcast background, Rich was a popular guest on radio and television and has appeared on national and international outlets including on CNN, MSNBC, NBC, Fox News, BBC, CBC, as well as local television and radio stations from Maryland to California. He has also either written, or been featured in, numerous newspaper and magazine articles. Rich operated TruthOrFiction.com until his death from pancreatic cancer in May of 2012, his family wrote and operated truthorfiction.com on his behalf until late 2018 and are still owners of the site.

The Hunters Who End up Dynamiting A Brand New SUV and Their Dog on a Frozen Lake-Fiction!

 
 
Summary of eRumor:
It's a tragic tale with a twist.  Two hunters use a stick of dynamite to make a hole big enough in a frozen lake to set themselves up for duck hunting.  When they light the stick of dynamite, their faithful retriever fetches it.  They try to shoot the dog, but he runs for cover...which turns out to be underneath one of the hunters' shiny new Lincoln Navigator (there are versions saying it was a different SUV such as a Jeep Cherokee).   The dynamite blows, the dog goes, the ice opens, and the SUV drops to the bottom of the lake.  The insurance doesn't cover it, so the hunter is left with his payments and no SUV.
The Truth:
 
It's an entertaining story, but it is an urban legend.  There are several versions of it that change the make and model of the SUV from version to version.
This is a common scenario for some urban legends.  There is a similar story about a fisherman who decided to use a stick of dynamite to stun a pool of fish and his dog jumps in grabs the dynamite and returns to his master's side.  There are also stories of hunted animals turning the tables on the hunters when they tried to use dynamite on their prey.
Besides, don't ducks fly south for the Winter?