Truth or Fiction?
Menu

Truth or Fiction?

'Facebook's Top Ten' on Twitter Abruptly Changes

Kim LaCapria
Kim LaCapria is a New York-based Content Manager, fact checker, and folklore enthusiast. She began debunking viral urban legends full-time in 2009, and in 2014 became the first editorial employee of Snopes.com, authoring thousands of political and viral fact checks. For several years, she worked to modernize the site and broaden its profile and scope. Those efforts came to fruition in 2016, leading to acclaim and global acknowledgement of the necessity for fact-checking and its role in slowing mis-and-disinformation on social media. Kim joined TruthOrFiction.com in December 2018. After work, she enjoys air hockey, water parks, jjimjilbangs, and internet culture.

On September 28 2021, a single tweet from the "Facebook's Top 10" Twitter account became notable not for what it showed, but for what it didn't:

https://twitter.com/FacebooksTop10/status/1442858419568852993

The account, which was created in July 2020 and is curated by New York Times tech journalist Kevin Roose, publishes daily tweets concerning the sources of "the 10 top-performing link posts by U.S. Facebook pages every day, ranked by total interactions." On September 28 2021, the list read:

1. Insider
2. CNN
3. CNN
4. Occupy Democrats
5. The New York Times
6. The Onion
7. Peachy Sunday
8. HuffPost
9. NPR
10. Reuters

By itself, the list of outlets was not inherently remarkable. Its sources -- CNN, The New York Times, The Onion, and NPR among them -- were fairly mundane.

What made the list notable was its deviation from the norm, as seen in previous "Facebook's Top 10" tweets:

https://twitter.com/FacebooksTop10/status/1442502056065974283
https://twitter.com/FacebooksTop10/status/1441432813891309568
https://twitter.com/FacebooksTop10/status/1438169777717927937

Readers shared the list and speculated that Facebook had "changed the algorithm" due to "bad press" or federal grilling:

https://twitter.com/ballfootski/status/1442896420051173378
https://twitter.com/andrewkimmel/status/1442886256543866880
https://twitter.com/_Liz_Kitteh_/status/1442902008340496392

Progressive media-centric site Media Matters for America (MMFA) shared a useful GIF image of several days' tweets from the Facebook's Top 10 account, and attributed the shake-up to then-recent news developments concerning R. Kelly:

https://twitter.com/mmfa/status/1442907942739529735
https://twitter.com/mmfa/status/1442908177327030275

However, the reasons for the switch, whether algorithmically or socially derived, were not immediately clear.

On September 28 2021, the "Facebook's Top 10" Twitter account shared their daily list -- immediately leading to discourse about the sudden absence of hyperpartisan, primarily right-wing commentary. It is true that the list changed fairly dramatically and virtually overnight -- but as is often the case, determining what (if anything) happened remained difficult due to Facebook's ongoing lack of transparency.