Truth or Fiction?
Menu

Truth or Fiction?

Fact Checks

Did 'Black Friday' Originally Refer to the Sale of Enslaved Men?

A rumor about the origins of the phrase "Black Friday" saw new life online in late 2014 amid a call for a shopping boycott of the traditional high-water day for retailers. As MarketWatch reported that December: A message posted on New York Knicks guard J.R. Smith's Instagram page on Nov. 25 (now...

Read more →

Were Blood Oranges from Libya Injected with HIV?

A popular rumor about oranges or bananas from outside the United States being injected with HIV- or AIDS-contaminated blood seems to circulate endlessly on social media despite having no basis in reality. This seems to be a spin on the popular (and completely unfounded) " foreigners carry diseases...

Read more →

Do Girl Scout Cookies Fund Planned Parenthood?

Attempts by right-wing groups to gin up allegations against the Girl Scouts of the USA have centered on linking them to Planned Parenthood and accusing them of embracing "radical" concepts like reproductive choice. In one instance, the head of the anti-choice group "Family Watch International"...

Read more →

Were Millions of Turkeys Recalled in 2014 Because of an Avian Flu Outbreak?

A "satire" blog's attempt at a Thanksgiving post in November 2014 is no less fabricated today, but real life did end up resembling this form of "art" years later. The National Report's post (which is no longer accessible on its website) stated: Researchers at the National Turkey Producers...

Read more →

Salvation Army Instructed Bell Ringers Not to Say 'Merry Christmas'?

In an early iteration of the ginned-up "War on Christmas" narrative, an email forward that was turned into a social media rumor pushed the claim that the Salvation Army had barred people volunteering as bell-ringers seeking donations for the group to say "Merry Christmas" during their shifts. In...

Read more →

'Christmas With Louise'

A story by comedian Jeff Foxworthy turned into an online chain letter -- but as it spread, his involvement was erased. The story, "Christmas with Louise," was published as part of Foxworthy's 1996 book No Shirt. No Shoes....No Problem! and involves Foxworthy deciding to "fulfill" his brother's...

Read more →

Was a Gigantic Crocodile Captured in New Orleans After Hurricane Katrina?

Among the disinformation and urban legends that circulated online in the wake of Hurricane Katrina in August 2005 was a chain email and photo that served as a precursor to meme culture. The story, often passed around with the subject line "Wow, Now this is a big crocodile Believe it or not!,"...

Read more →

Did Hurricane Katrina Cause Gasoline Rationing?

One of the disinformation chain emails that circulated in connection to Hurricane Katrina in August 2005 was so flimsy, it finally stopped cold. Like many messages of its type, the email was presented as an anecdote about workers at an oil refinery being warned by their supervisor to "keep their...

Read more →

'Infidels' Email Forward

Although iterations of an email forward known as "WHAT IS AN INFIDEL?" appeared on Facebook in 2019, it began circulating no later than 2004. Its content largely represented the original author's opinions and perspectives on Islam, and was not a neutral or fact-based statement about any specific...

Read more →

Did Hillary Clinton 'Cut in Line' for Thanksgiving Dinner with Troops in Afghanistan?

Former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton's November 2003 visit to U.S. troops in Afghanistan was spun into a fanciful tale of liberal pique online, framed in some iterations as a concerned email from an actual veteran. Clinton, who was a senator representing New York state at the time, did indeed...

Read more →

Is This Soldier Covertly Showing He Was Coerced into Shaking Hands With Hillary Clinton?

This rumor started circulating shortly after then-Senator Hillary Clinton made a Thanksgiving visit to the soldiers in Iraq in 2003. It includes a picture of a U.S. soldier shaking hands with Sen. Clinton. He is also crossing the fingers of his left hand, which the email says is a soldier's sign...

Read more →

George Carlin and 'The Paradox of Our Age'

An essay that has spent years mistakenly attributed to comedian George Carlin circulates in perpetuity in a popular "copypasta" post shared via email and on Facebook posts. The essay, "The Paradox of Our Age" (which has also been called "The Paradox of Our Time"), has been framed as a message from...

Read more →

Walmart Cash Back 'New Scam' Warning

In November 2019 a Facebook warning about a "new scam" involving cash back began circulating on Facebook, suggesting that cashiers were pilfering cash from customers' credit or debit cards by surreptitiously engaging the "cash back" option for those who declined to take a receipt:...

Read more →

Did a Veterans' Hospital Refuse to Allow 'Merry Christmas' Cards to be Delivered?

In an especially egregious bit of holiday-related disinformation, a right-wing Fox News personality published a claim that debunked itself. The claim stemmed from a December 2013 op-ed by Todd Starnes, who accused the federal Veterans Administration (VA) hospital in Dallas of refusing to take...

Read more →

Talking Angela iPhone App Warning

Example : [Gathered on Facebook in February 2019, archived here ] WARNING TO ALL PARENTS WITH CHILDREN THAT HAVE ANY ELECTRONIC DEVICES , EX : IPOD,TABLETS ETC .... THERE IS A SITE CALLED TALKING ANGELA , THIS SITE ASKS KIDS QUESTIONS LIKE : THERE NAMES , WHERE THEY GO TO SCHOOL AND ALSO TAKE...

Read more →

Did Target Say No to the Salvation Army While Selling Sex Toys?

The Target retail chain's stance toward sex toys appears to have changed since right-wing religious groups criticized it in 2004 for limiting its association with the Salvation Army. Going into late 2004, the American Family Association (AFA) complained that the retail chain would not allow...

Read more →

Did Pat Sajak Insult People Worried About Climate Change on Twitter?

In May 2014, game show host Pat Sajak abandoned his previously apolitical bent to wade into climate science discussions online, purportedly "just to hear the buzzing." That month, Sajak (best known for appearing for decades on the daytime television show Wheel of Fortune , in which contestants try...

Read more →

A Proposed 28th Amendment That Says 'Congress Will Make No Laws That Does Not Apply to Them'?

A forwarded-email-turned-social-media-post about a proposed "28th amendment" to the United States Constitution pops up periodically as a viral rumor. There are variations, but the gist of it goes something like this: Congress shall make no law that applies to the citizens of the United States that...

Read more →

Did a Maryland School Require Students To Cross Dress?

The transphobia at the root of a "satirical" post from late 2013 continued to play out in real-life situations in early 2022. The post -- a fabricated account of panic at a Maryland middle school -- was first published on "nationalreport.net," a long-running blog specializing in fringe-level...

Read more →

Do Unauthorized Immigrants Cost U.S. Taxpayers $338.3 Billion a Year?

An ancient rumor about the purported costs of undocumented workers in the United States reappears whenever politicians use immigration as a platform, which is to say just about annually. Studies on how much undocumented people cost United States taxpayers each year vary greatly, but this rumor's...

Read more →