Truth or Fiction?
Fact Checks
11-Year-Old Girl With Shotgun Stops Invaders?
Since 2007, a rumor about a young girl with a gun (Patricia Harrington) and two undocumented people breaking in (Ralphel Resindez and Enrico Garcia) plays on xenophobia and fear to make its point during its cyclical appearances on Facebook and in email boxes: Shotgun Preteen vs. Illegal alien Home...
Read more →Were Butterball Turkeys Sold in the United States 'Blessed by Allah'?
Anti-Muslim blogger Pamela Geller attempted to gin up controversy in 2011 by painting Thanksgiving dinners as being targeted by a non-existent Islamic "threat" in a little seasonal racism that recurs nearly every year. In a post that November, Geller expanded on a claim she had made the previous...
Read more →Cancer Warning about Baby Cut Carrots
Baby carrots do not come out of the ground the way they appear in bags at the supermarket. Because of this, rumors abound at how they are truly made and what it entails, sometimes in meme form: For years, California has produced the majority of carrots sold in the United States; the process of...
Read more →Photos of Trash in the Arizona Desert Left Behind by 'Illegal Immigrants'?
A photograph showing trash and debris scattered across a desert landscape comes as part of a chain email that says it is an "eye-opener" from the Sonoran Desert region in Arizona, showing a trash-covered landscape: According to chain emails and Facebook posts, thousands of backpacks, clothes, food...
Read more →Did a Florida Court Name April 1 as a Holiday for Atheists?
An evangelical "gotcha" meme that originated as an email continues to linger online, as such detritus often does, as both text copypasta and in graphic form. The meme is set inside a Florida courthouse, where an atheist and his attorney has filed a lawsuit, described here as "a discrimination case...
Read more →Did 'a Muslim Man' Disrupt a Concert in the Netherlands?
Several versions of a story about an unidentified "Muslim man" who disrupted a concert in the Netherlands to invite Queen Beatrix of Holland to the Islamic faith reappear regularly with various details added, changed, or outright omitted. Some versions say the man was the orchestra conductor, and...
Read more →Did Best Buy Release a Holiday Shopping Ad With a Greeting for Muslim Shoppers?
The Best Buy tech store chain was attacked by "Christians" and right-wing online users in 2009 after it included a Muslim holiday in its set of holiday season advertisements. The company did indeed release an ad that year that included the greeting, "Happy Eid al-Adha": The ad was not unique, or...
Read more →'Hijacking Dry Run' on AirTran Airways Flight 297?
Summary of eRumor: This eRumor is said to be from a man who was aboard an airplane about to depart from Atlanta, Georgia when there was a disturbance which he describes as prompted by a group of 11 “Muslim men got on the plane in full attire” and “peppered themselves throughout the plane.” They...
Read more →Was Facebook Selling Users' Photos to Advertisers?
In July 2009, Facebook faced criticism over alleged sharing of its users' photographs -- a prelude to even bigger controversies as the platform's influence grew. If you were on the platform over the last decade or so, you might have seen people posting some version of this: Don’t forget tomorrow...
Read more →Did George Soros Try to 'Control' the Gun Industry?
In a testament to both the recurring nature of right-wing disinformation and its reliance on billionaire George Soros as a boogeyman, a shoddy claim from 2011 accusing him of wanting to dominate the U.S. firearms market was recycled just four years later to further spread online, and it has...
Read more →'Avoid Shopping Malls on Halloween'
As we have noted before, chain e-mails helped spread their own form of disinformation following the 9-11 attacks in New York City and Washington, D.C. in September 2001. One of them spread within a month of the attacks, sowing fear of a follow-up incident that October and relayed as an anecdote...
Read more →
Is it Illegal for Americans to Have Contact With Extraterrestrials?
For years, conspiracy-minded social media users trying to sound smart by "just asking questions" have floated a conspiracy theory that is particularly moon-brained. Most iterations of the post ask: If the government has no knowledge of aliens, then why does Title 14, Section 1211 of the Code of...
Read more →Would a Senate Bill Ban Schoolbooks from Mentioning 'Mom' and 'Dad'?
The disinformation around a piece of legislation in California in 2006 shows how what was once an imagined threat for right-wing blogs became the actual basis of right-wing political policy against LGBTQ+ Americans. The blog "World News Daily" spun a post distorting the intent of SB 1437 at that...
Read more →'Obama Signed the SNAP Fairness Act of 2014'
A short-lived "satirical" website made a bid for attention in December 2014 by combining two favorite targets of the right wing: then-U.S. President Barack Obama, and poor people. That month the "Salty Badger" published a post claiming that had signed the "SNAP Fairness Act of 2014" into law,...
Read more →'Clinton Body Count' Rumors
This page is a work in progress and we are in the process of updating older archived materials. Please check back regularly for more information. Stories about mysterious deaths of people associated with the Clintons have been around since the 1990s. The "Clinton body count" list apparently...
Read more →Was 'The Gold and Ivory Tablecloth' Based on a True Story?
A story first published in Reader's Digest in 1954 continues to linger online -- only without any sort of confirmation. "The Gold and Ivory Tablecloth" by Rev. Howard C. Schade deals with a chance encounter that leads to a touching reunion. "At Christmastime, men and women everywhere gather in...
Read more →Is 'The Twelve Days of Christmas' a Song About Catechism?
A priest's 1995 blog post helped circulate a claim about the origin of the song "The 12 Days of Christmas," casting it as a secret act of religious resistance, before later walking back his claims. The Rev. Harold Richard Stockert (also known as "Father Hal") said in a post for the Catholic...
Read more →
The Long History of the 'Slavery Tax Refund' Scam
For years, the idea of Black Americans receiving compensation for the atrocities inflicted upon them as part of the slave trade has been the lure for a strain of disinformation that also served as a scam targeting senior communities. Like a lot of disinformation online, the scam -- which has gone...
Read more →Are Poinsettia Plants Poisonous to Children and Pets?
A longstanding misconception about poinsettia plants has continued to linger online thanks to social media, but more sources have come out debunking the claim. As of November 2022 it has been more than a century since the plants gained a reputation for being poisonous. As the British scientific...
Read more →Did a Needle Infected With HIV Inside a McDonald's Kill a Child?
The spread of a chain e-mail, reportedly spotted online around the year 2000, demonstrated how easily bad actors can fearmonger around illicit substances -- and how those rumors and narratives get used and re-used over the years. Most variations on the message are presented as a story from one...
Read more →