Truth or Fiction?
Menu

Truth or Fiction?

Hatsune Miku and Harry Potter

Kim LaCapria
Kim LaCapria is a New York-based Content Manager, fact checker, and folklore enthusiast. She began debunking viral urban legends full-time in 2009, and in 2014 became the first editorial employee of Snopes.com, authoring thousands of political and viral fact checks. For several years, she worked to modernize the site and broaden its profile and scope. Those efforts came to fruition in 2016, leading to acclaim and global acknowledgement of the necessity for fact-checking and its role in slowing mis-and-disinformation on social media. Kim joined TruthOrFiction.com in December 2018. After work, she enjoys air hockey, water parks, jjimjilbangs, and internet culture.

On December 19 2019, "Hatsune Miku" trended on Twitter during a controversy involving J.K. Rowling, Harry Potter, and trans-exclusionary feminism ("TERF," an abbreviation for "trans-exclusionary radical feminist" also trended.)

That morning, Rowling had confirmed long-circulating rumors that she supported "gender-critical" feminism, also known as trans-exclusionary feminism, when she tweeted:

https://twitter.com/jk_rowling/status/1207646162813100033

As noted above, "Hatsune Miku" consistently trended alongside J.K. Rowling's name and "TERF." The meme appeared to have emerged from a similar controversy earlier in 2019, involving the creator of the game Minecraft:

Microsoft is hosting a ten year celebration event on May 17 [2019] for seminal game Minecraft. A spokesperson from Microsoft told Variety that Markus “Notch” Persson, the original creator of Minecraft and founder of game studio Mojang, has been purposefully excluded from the event due to his past comments. “His comments and opinions do not reflect those of Microsoft or Mojang and are not representative of Minecraft,” the spokesperson told Variety.

[...]

In the past several years, Persson, who currently has 3.7 million twitter followers, has broadcasted several controversial and frankly abhorrent opinions and views regarding politics, race, gender, and sexuality, and even full-blown conspiracy theories.

On March 29 2019, a fan/parody account for the character Hatsune Miku retweeted Persson, and added:

https://twitter.com/mikumiku_ebooks/status/1111773445870796801?lang=en

At the same time, fans of Minecraft also joked the game "came from space":

https://twitter.com/zarawesome/status/1070808886167375874
https://twitter.com/foone/status/1114371644586319872

The meme was readily available when Harry Potter fans felt disappointment at Rowling's opinions on transgender people. Within a few hours, many fans began praising Hatsune Miku for creating the Harry Potter series:

https://twitter.com/theturtlebyte/status/1207691820748066817
https://twitter.com/HitsuTM/status/1207733290888761347
https://twitter.com/HYENABLOOD/status/1207721410732470273

Agreement wasn't unanimous, however:

https://twitter.com/luulubuu/status/1207718340459978752

Oopular tweets about Hitsune Miku authoring Harry Potter books are a meme, a rapid response to news about J.K. Rowling's tweet voicing support for trans-exclusionary feminism. An alternative, less prominent iteration of the meme claimed that Rowling's works "came from space."