Truth or Fiction?
Menu

Truth or Fiction?

Immigration

“I Smell a Rat” Column on Syrian Refugees by Eli Gordon-Fiction!

“I Smell a Rat” Column on Syrian Refugees by Eli Gordon- Fiction! Summary of eRumor: The “I Smell a Rat” column written by a so-called Canadian historian named Eli Gordon raises questions about immigrants fleeing the Syrian civil war in what it calls “sudden vast numbers.” The Truth: There’s no...

Read more →

Bill Still Report Updates Claim that UPS Smuggled Refugees on Plane-Fiction!

Bill Still Report Updates Claim that UPS Smuggled Refugees on Plane- Fiction! Summary of eRumor: Author and filmmaker Bill Still has followed up on reports that a UPS cargo plane smuggled illegal immigrants into the country at an airport in Harrison, Pennsylvania. The Truth: There’s still no proof...

Read more →

Were Muslims Banned From Entering the United States in 1952?

A 1952 American immigration law intended to end the discrimination of immigrants based on "race and creed" became an argument to keep specific immigrants out of the United States in 2015, when Donald Trump, then the Republican presidential candidate, released a statement calling for “a total and...

Read more →

Did Jimmy Carter Ban Iranians from Entering the U.S.?

As right-wing bloggers and social media users tried to defend one of Donald Trump's early attack on Muslims in December 2015, they misleadingly compared his rhetoric to a measure taken by Democrat Jimmy Carter during his presidency. At the time the comparisons began, presidential candidate Trump,...

Read more →

Were Anne Frank and Her Family Denied Entry Into the U.S.?

In the years since her death, Anne Frank has become a symbol of the effects of both fascism and political xenophobia. But a group named in her honor has debunked one of the more prolific online legends about her. Born in Germany in February 1929, Frank came to prominence posthumously following the...

Read more →

Was UPS Bringing Refugees into the U.S. on Cargo Flights?

A xenophobic conspiracy theory video floated on Facebook in November 2015 not only remains active on the platform in 2023, but was pushed by political candidates as recently as 2022. The footage -- literally a driver filming a bus in front of him at night -- pushes the claim that United Parcel...

Read more →

Were 10,000 Syrian Refugees Relocated to New Orleans?

Not long after some far-right blogs tried to paint Michigan as a "victim" of a wave of Syrian refugees, some of their cohorts attempted to gin up the same xenophobic panic in Louisiana. The claim originated as an " alert " that a " flood " of refugees would be steered toward the U.S., with three...

Read more →

Denmark Has Banned Muslims from the Country-Mostly Fiction!

Denmark Has Banned Muslims from the Country- Mostly Fiction! Summary of eRumor: Denmark has banned Muslim refugees and immigrants from settling in the country. The Truth: Denmark has not banned Muslims, but the country has tightened immigration laws and has made the religious slaughter of animals...

Read more →

Female Physician in Munich Pens Email About Refugee Crisis-Unproven!

Female Physician in Munich Pens Email About Refugee Crisis- Unproven! Summary of eRumor: A female physician from Munich described in an email the challenge of providing medical care to refugees from Syria and other Middle Eastern countries who have come to Germany. The Truth: We can’t confirm the...

Read more →

10,000 Passports Seized in Bulgaria Were Bound for Islamic Terrorists-Truth! & Fiction!

10,000 Passports Seized in Bulgaria Were Bound for Islamic Terrorists- Truth! & Fiction! Summary of eRumor: Officials in Bulgaria seized a box of 10,000 fake Syrian passports that were going to be given to Islamic terrorists to gain entry into Europe. The Truth: It’s true that 10,000 fake Syrian...

Read more →

Photos Show Tramp Steamer Full of Immigrants Headed from Libya to Italy-Fiction!

Photos Show Tramp Steamer Full of Immigrants Headed from Libya to Italy- Fiction! Summary of eRumor: Forwarded emails show photos of a tramp steamer ship packed full of immigrants that are reportedly headed from Libya to Italy. The Truth: These photos don’t show a tramp steamer ship bound from...

Read more →

Were 4,500 Syrian Refugees Relocated to a Michigan Town?

In a testament to how easily xenophobic disinformation can spread online multiple times over, two different blogs attracted attention by rehashing the same fake claim about Syrian refugees, but years apart. The claim that at least 4,500 Syrians escaping the war in their country would be relocated...

Read more →

Polish Blogger Kamil Bulonis’s Account of “Third-World Invasion” of Refugees-Reported as Fiction!

Polish Blogger Kamil Bulonis’s Account of “Third-World Invasion” of Refugees- Reported as Fiction! Summary of eRumor: Polish blogger and reality television star Kamil Bulonis saw a throng of Syrian refugees attack a bus at the Italian-Austrian border and then blogged about changing his leftist...

Read more →

Claims About the Federal Government's "Operation Wetback"-Truth! & Fiction!

Claims About the Federal Government's "Operation Wetback" - Truth! & Fiction! Summary of eRumor: A chain email claims that a federal effort to deport illegal aliens in the 1950s called “Operation Wetback” led to the removal of 13 million illegal aliens. The Truth: Operation Wetback was a real...

Read more →

Journalist Tina Griego Penned a Column Titled "Mexican Visitor's Lament"-Incorrect Attribution!

Journalist Tina Griego Penned a Column Titled "Mexican Visitor's Lament" - Incorrect Attribution! Summary of eRumor: Tina Griego, a journalist for the Denver Rocky Mountain News , wrote a column titled “Mexican Visitor’s Lament” that talks about the benefits of 20 million illegal aliens immediately...

Read more →

List of 'Facts and Figures' About Undocumented Immigrants?

Immigration is a topic filled with disinformation and misinformation, which is often offered up in fact-free (but media-friendly) soundbites and their online corollary, memes. That they often contain no citation whatsoever is no hindrance to their spread. One such enduring meme, which incidentally...

Read more →

Do Unauthorized Immigrants Cost U.S. Taxpayers $338.3 Billion a Year?

An ancient rumor about the purported costs of undocumented workers in the United States reappears whenever politicians use immigration as a platform, which is to say just about annually. Studies on how much undocumented people cost United States taxpayers each year vary greatly, but this rumor's...

Read more →

Photos of Trash in the Arizona Desert Left Behind by 'Illegal Immigrants'?

A photograph showing trash and debris scattered across a desert landscape comes as part of a chain email that says it is an "eye-opener" from the Sonoran Desert region in Arizona, showing a trash-covered landscape: According to chain emails and Facebook posts, thousands of backpacks, clothes, food...

Read more →