Truth or Fiction?
Truth or Fiction?
Seeking truth, exposing fiction
United States Air Traffic on September 11, 2001
In September 2019, approaching the eighteenth anniversary of September 11th 2011, a Reddit user shared the following GIF purportedly depicting United States air traffic during and after the attacks to r/DamnThatsInteresting :...
Read more →Is This the Only Existing Footage Of the First Plane Hitting the World Trade Center?
As the anniversary of September 11 2001 approached in 2019, a video called "The Only Existing Footage Of 1st Plane Hitting WTC" circulated on social media in remembrance of a brief but pivotal moment in American history — but it's straight from a disinformation site. That video was first shared to...
Read more →Does Trump Have a 94 Percent Approval Rating with Republicans?
On September 9 2019, President Donald Trump used his Twitter account to push a claim of record popularity that has already been debunked by several news organizations. For the fourth time in three months, Trump boasted that he had a "94 percent" approval rating within the Republican Party, calling...
Read more →Did a Pastor Die After 30 Days of Fasting to Beat Jesus Christ's Record?
In September 2019, an article with the headline "Pastor Dies After 30 Days of Fasting To Beat Jesus Record" appeared in several Facebook groups and users' feeds: A South African pastor, Alfred Ndlovu has died of malnutrition after going without food for 30 days when he tried to emulate Jesus Christ...
Read more →Is the United States the 118th Safest Country in the World — Down From 65th in 2018?
A September 3 2019 tweet (shared to Facebook the following day) contained the alarming claim that the United States was ranked the 118th safest country in the world in 2019, dropping from the 65th spot in 2018: https://twitter.com/ResisterSiano/status/1168761801498124288 That tweet was shared...
Read more →Did the Detective Who Led Jeffrey Epstein Investigation Die after a 'Brief Illness' At 50 in September 2019?
In early September 2019, a large number of Facebook users shared an article ( archived here ), compellingly titled "Detective Who Led Epstein Investigation Died After 'Brief Illness' At 50." Based on the visible shares to Facebook alone, readers found the title and excerpt so convincing they may...
Read more →Palindrome Week, September 2019
On September 9 2019 and subsequently, a "palindrome week" meme circulated on Twitter: https://www.facebook.com/news6/photos/a.386444532209/10157639659427210/?type=3&theater Above 10 dates ranging from September 10 to 19 2019, text read: PALINDROME WEEK Each date reads the same backwards and...
Read more →United States Officials Blame 'Confusion' After Viral Video of Hurricane Evacuees Turned Away
As video spread of more than a hundred Hurricane Dorian evacuees from the Bahamas being told they could not escape the damage by coming to the United States on September 9, 2019 if they did not have a visa, immigration officials blamed a local ferry company — while U.S. President Donald Trump cast...
Read more →Did a Swedish Scientist Propose Cannibalism to Fight Climate Change?
On September 7 2019, United States President Donald Trump retweeted a Breitbart.com post that suggested a Swedish scientist had proposed that cannibalism was a viable solution to fight climate change: https://twitter.com/BreitbartNews/status/1170360020195774465 A headline with the tweet said it...
Read more →Jim Carrey Depression Meme: 'I Believe Depression is Legitimate. But...'
A July 5 2019 Instagram post purportedly quoting actor Jim Carrey on depression appeared on Facebook in screenshot form. The original featured an image of the actor and attributed the following quote to him: https://www.instagram.com/p/BzjHmVeH66U/?hl=en That unverified account, jimcarrey__,...
Read more →911 Dispatcher Donna Reneau/Debra Stevens Drowning Incident
On September 1 2019, the following meme appeared in the Facebook group "LIVE PD FANS NO BOUNDARIES" ( archived here ), purportedly detailing an exchange between the woman shown in the photograph (911 dispatcher Donna Reneau) and a victim of flash flooding (Debra Stevens): The text over her head in...
Read more →Weather Agency Contradicts Itself Over Trump's Hurricane 'Forecast'
The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) disavowed its own agency's findings in a brief statement on September 6 2019, siding with United States President Donald Trump amid allegations that the president may have illegally altered a map displaying the potential impact of Hurricane...
Read more →Does the Australian 'Gympie-Gympie' Drive People to Suicide?
While the damage caused by the plant species Dendrocnide moroides has been recounted in various outlets, one graphic spreading in August 2019 adds apocryphal claims to the stories around it. The graphic shows a photograph of the plant, commonly known as the " Gympie-Gympie ," with a caption...
Read more →Are School Bus Stops Now More Dangerous Because of an All-Time High in Human Trafficking?
A back-to-school themed Facebook warning shared on September 5 2019 ( archived here ) declared that all school-age children must avoid all school bus stops because of an increased threat of human trafficking: https://www.facebook.com/lionel.rush1/posts/2950521358298017 Against a pastel background,...
Read more →Did Reykjavik Ensure That Pride Flags Were Prominently Flown to Greet Mike Pence?
On September 4 2019, Twitter user @Heklina shared the following tweet showing a number of gay flags and with commentary about U.S. Vice President Mike Pence's visit to Iceland: https://twitter.com/Heklina/status/1169307235098533888 Another version was shared by Facebook page "The Iron Snowflake."...
Read more →Dear 'Ban Gun' Teenagers, 11 Teens Die a Day from Texting and Driving
Facebook status memes about guns in general consistently appear in the now nearly constant wake of mass shootings , but a February 2018 iteration ( archived here ) aimed at "'ban gun' teenagers" puts forth an insincere argument targeting texting and driving instead:...
Read more →Are Japanese Students Exempt from Taking Exams Until the Fourth Grade?
Some social media users and blogs looking to criticize the American educational system have seized on citing its Japanese counterpart as an aspirational example. But at least one widely-circulated example hinges on a lack of context. The claim has been spread on both websites and memes with some...
Read more →'10,874 People Killed by Drunk Drivers in 2017, 403 by Rifles but Walmart Stops Selling Rifles' Meme
On September 3 2019, the Facebook page "Life's Short Live Free" shared the following meme commentary ( archived here ), discussing Walmart discontinuing the sale of some firearms:...
Read more →The Love Letters of Gilbert Bradley and Gordon Bowsher
Various memes detailing a secret relationship between two British men during World War II described in various posts circulated through social media in August 2019. One post about Gilbert Bradley and Gordon Bowsher, and the correspondence they kept through the war, has been shared more than 10,000...
Read more →Did Canada Agree to Take in 100,000 Palestinians?
A story first attributed to a media outlet in Lebanon has prompted criticism and a public denial from the Canadian government, which flatly called it misinformation. On September 4 2019, AlAkhbar.com reported that, per an agreement between Canada and the United States, the former country would...
Read more →