Truth or Fiction?
Truth or Fiction?
Seeking truth, exposing fiction
Disney, Ariel, and the ‘White Mermaids’ Dispute
In early July 2019, Haile Bailey's casting as main character Ariel in a live-action reboot of Disney's animated film The Little Mermaid caused controversy on social media, sparking a meme about another person of color having appeared in the original animated television series from the early 1990s....
Read more →Did Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez Say If 'Owning Guns Was a Right It Would Be in the Constitution'?
New York Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-New York) has captured the attention of the internet and its trolls, which means that memes and rumors about her are quite common — most of which seem to attribute either motives or quotes to her with no citation or evidence. One such meme, which has...
Read more →Did a Symbolic Random Chat Room Name Appear After Etika's Death?
After the death of YouTube gaming streamer Etika was confirmed in late June 2019, his on-and-off girlfriend Alice Pika hosted a memorial livestream on June 26 2019. Not long after, a rumor circulated on Reddit and other sites about what the appearance of a random name that was interpreted as a sign...
Read more →Sparkler Ash Dog Death Warning
On June 26 2019, a Facebook user posted the following story about the death of their pug Zoe, urging other users to be aware of the purported danger posed by spent firework and sparkler ash: https://www.facebook.com/james.copp.50/posts/1469037729905895 In part of the post, Copp said that Zoe had...
Read more →Did Colin Kaepernick Force Nike to Cancel 'Offensive' Betsy Ross American Flag Sneakers?
On July 1 2019, the Wall Street Journal published an article reporting that Nike had canceled shipment of a planned Betsy Ross flag-themed sneaker , adding that former NFL quarterback Colin Kaepernick had forced the athletic wear company to do so as he found the design offensive. The New York Times...
Read more →Did Protesters Throw 'Concrete Milkshakes'?
Dueling protests became dueling narratives in Portland, Oregon on June 29 2019 when clashes erupted between Proud Boys attendees and anti-fascist demonstrators, quickly devolving into rumors that milkshakes thrown at one person contained one or more damaging or caustic substances — including...
Read more →Did a Woman on Facebook Mistake Drill Bits Discarded at a Gas Station for Bullets?
In March 2018, the Facebook page "Historical Pictures" shared the following meme ( archived here ), purportedly a screenshot of a Facebook post in which a woman named Emily Noel mistakes discarded drill bits for bullets:...
Read more →Did Dwight Eisenhower Say Someday 'Someone Will Claim It Never Happened' in 1945?
On June 9 2019, the Facebook page "No To Theocracy" shared the following meme ( archived here ), featuring a quote in which President Dwight Eisenhower appeared to have predicted Holocaust denial: https://www.facebook.com/176892342366434/photos/a.810757058979956/2211639368891711/?type=3&theater...
Read more →Did a Man Get Plastic Surgery and Change His Name to Circumvent a Restraining Order?
A December 2018 article headlined , "Man gets plastic surgery and name change to date his ex-girlfriend after she obtains restraining order" has appeared intermittently on social media after its publication. No obvious date appeared on the apparent news story, which claimed: A New Jersey man who...
Read more →Did Socrates Say 'When Debate is Lost, Slander Becomes the Tool of the Losers'?
On June 26 2019, Eric Trump tweeted a meme attributing a quote about slander to the philosopher Socrates: https://twitter.com/EricTrump/status/1144004337842229248 Against an image of what appeared to be a black and white photograph of a statue of Socrates in Athens, text read: When the debate is...
Read more →Dr. Seuss 'Foreign Children' Comic
In June 2019, the following meme featuring a quote by a Fox News personality and a purported comic by Dr. Seuss on "foreign children" circulated on social media: At the top of the meme was a screenshot of Fox News' Fox & Friends, and a June 2018 quote from Brian Kilmeade during the show. Kilmeade...
Read more →There Is No Credible Evidence Rep. Ilhan Omar Married Her Brother
On June 23 2019 pundit Dinesh D'Souza tweeted a very old claim: That Rep. Ilhan Omar (D-Minnesota) once married her own brother: https://twitter.com/DineshDSouza/status/1142810127826870272 In the tweet above, D'Souza claims without citation or evidence that Omar "married her brother to evade...
Read more →Does It Cost $750 a Day to House Migrant Children in Camps?
In June 2019, social media posts popped up claiming that that it costs taxpayers $750 (or $775) per child per day to house immigrant children in "tent cities" and other detention facilities. A June 22 2019 post on the Facebook page " Your Privilege Is Showing " was shared nearly 10,000 times, and...
Read more →Does a Photograph Show Rosaries Confiscated from Border Detainees?
In June 2018, a Facebook user shared a post ( archived here ) featuring a screenshot of a tweet about rosary beads purportedly confiscated from migrants taken into custody by border agents. That post was shared more than 89,000 times in a year. The tweet was originally published on the same date,...
Read more →Did U.S. President Barack Obama Have a Separation Policy at the Border?
In late June 2019, United States President Donald Trump repeatedly claimed that his administration did not have a family separation policy at the border — going further to attribute the controversial actions to his predecessor, Barack Obama. Trump outright stated this lie multiple times in a series...
Read more →Was Don Rickles Included in 'Toy Story 4' Thanks to Archival Material?
On June 23 2019, the Facebook page "Just Disney" shared a meme which claimed that the late Don Rickles' Mr. Potato Head character appeared in the feature film Toy Story 4 — despite his death in April 2017: https://www.facebook.com/JustDisney/photos/a.693522117498083/1164305700419720/?type=3&theater...
Read more →Did Donald Trump Send Six Tweets Warning President Barack Obama Would Attack Iran as a Diversion?
As tensions between the United States and Iran escalated in June 2019, a number of memes circulated that purportedly depicted tweets sent by Donald Trump between 2011 and 2013 — predicting that former United States President Barack Obama would fabricate a reason to attack Iran to divert attention...
Read more →Have Arrest Warrants Been Issued for Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama?
Despite fears of " deepfake " videos and other high-tech ways disinformation could potentially proliferate in the very near future, the stories that still get the most traction are often decidedly low effort. Take, for example, the case of a May 2019 story with the provocative headline "Panel of 16...
Read more →Did the Cook and Janitor of a Bankrupt Assisted Living Home Stay to Care for Abandoned Residents?
On June 16 2019, the Facebook page "Weird Facts" shared the following meme ( archived here ), about a cook and a janitor who purportedly refused to abandon the residents of a bankrupted care home: https://www.facebook.com/factsweird/photos/a.593359597348402/3395316713819329/?type=3&theater Atop an...
Read more →Did Malia Obama Cash a $1.2 Million Check?
A headline about former First Daughter Malia Obama (archived here ) depositing a suspiciously large check got a lot of traction on social media in June 2019: However, this story is suspect for two reasons. First, it contains little beyond a provocative headline, a photograph, and a few lines of...
Read more →