Truth or Fiction?
Truth or Fiction?
Seeking truth, exposing fiction
Was 'Proud Boy' Rob Cantrell Photographed at a Right-Wing Protest in Michigan?
The photograph that came to symbolize the hypocrisy present in an anti-government protest in Michigan on April 30 2020 became the center of an unfounded allegation concerning its origins. The image, showing an unidentified man yelling at a group of police officers outside the state House of...
Read more →'Venice in Quarantine': Did Flamingos Flock to Quiet Canals?
Quirky or uplifting news was in high demand as the COVID-19 pandemic dragged on, which was likely the reason that a Facebook post ("Venice ... in quarantine," archived here ) purportedly showing flamingos in the deserted canals of Venice, Italy proved to be so popular:...
Read more →Are COVID-19 Doctors Reporting Bizarre Blood Clotting and Strokes in Otherwise Healthy Young Patients?
On May 3 2020, Twitter user Bess Kalb tweeted that her father, an intensive care unit doctor, claimed that COVID-19 damaged blood and vascular systems of victims like "sticking your finger in an electric socket": https://twitter.com/bessbell/status/1257057870136242176 Kalb followed with a thread,...
Read more →Was a Man in California Spotted Shopping While Wearing a Ku Klux Klan Hood?
Social media users and officials in a small southern California city condemned photographs spreading online showing an unidentified man shopping in public while wearing a Ku Klux Klan hood as a "face mask" during the first weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic. The man was first spotted and photographed...
Read more →Did a Right-Wing COVID-19 Protester Carry a Sign Displaying a Nazi Slogan?
Several photographs emerged online on May 1 2020 purportedly showing right-wing protesters -- and in one case a child -- displaying a Nazi slogan. But at least one of the images was manipulated digitally. As the Associated Press reported, a photograph of a woman holding up a sign saying "work sets...
Read more →The Viral Death of Kat Restin
Segments of Twitter are alight with rumors surrounding the April 2020 death of Virginia teenager Kat Restin and the alleged circumstances regarding her demise. An obituary for Restin, 19, was published on April 23 2020. In that obituary, Restin's name is given as "Katelynn Anne 'Kat' Restin," and...
Read more →Did Michigan Gov. Whitmer Need Protection From Armed Right-Wing Protesters?
As armed demonstrators descended on the Michigan statehouse in Lansing on April 30 2020, the footage became a point of contention online. The video, first posted by WDIV-TV business editor Rod Meloni, shows a group of protesters demanding to be let into the state House chambers. It was shared on...
Read more →Is CostCo Requiring Shoppers to Cover Their Faces?
As the CostCo retail chain prepared to implement new requirements for shoppers, a message of support for the policy gained traction among Facebook users. The post is based around a photograph of a sign informing shoppers that members will be required to wear face coverings when shopping at CostCo...
Read more →Did Elon Musk Tweet 'If One Day, My Words are Against Science, Choose Science' Before a COVID-19 Controversy?
As the COVID-19 pandemic progressed in the United States, dueling opinions were politicized and bluntly split between opinions based on hard science versus economics. This ended up leading to the recirculation of a purported tweet from Elon Musk about any of his putative future opinions "against...
Read more →'Wear Your Mask: The Urine Test' Analogy Meme
On April 29 2020, a post titled "Wear Your Mask: The Urine Test" appeared on r/funny (and soon r/all), aiming to explain the purpose of masks during the coronavirus pandemic to pants in the presence of a person uncontrollably urinating everywhere:...
Read more →Did Dolly Parton Help Fund Research for a COVID-19 Treatment?
Country music icon Dolly Parton's reputation for philanthropy grew in April 2020 after reports appeared of her involvement in research for an antibody treatment against COVID-19. The singer announced on her Instagram account on April 1 2020 that she would donate $1 million toward researchers at...
Read more →Is There 'No Scientific Proof' That Social Distancing Prevents the Spread of Coronavirus?
On April 22 2020, a KUSI News item ("USC Professor Joel Hay says there is no scientific proof social distancing prevents spread of coronavirus") appeared containing a claim that proved particularly popular among people who opposed COVID-19 social distancing measures -- orders typically described as...
Read more →Are Four Networks 'Set to Announce They Will No Longer Televise Trump's Announcements'?
Those perhaps seeking relief from live coverage of United States President Donald Trump's daily briefings on COVID-19 shared a Texas man's unverified claim that some major news outlets would stop carrying them in late April 2020. "CNN, NBC, CBS, & ABC are set to announce that they will no longer...
Read more →Medical Community Refutes Bakersfield Doctors' Attempts to Minimize COVID-19
Two California-based doctors' attempt to compare COVID-19 to the common flu has incurred criticism and debunking from not only their local colleagues, but medical professionals at the state and national level. In a rare step, the American College of Emergency Physicians (ACEP) and the American...
Read more →CNN 'Global Death Toll Approaches Three Million People' Chyron Error
On April 27 2020, a screen capture purportedly of CNN showing anchor Wolf Blitzer with a chyron reading "GLOBAL DEATH TOLL APPROACHES THREE MILLION PEOPLE" circulated on social media, often marked with question marks, circles, and an arrow: On the right side of the screen was a column titled...
Read more →'Quarantine is When You Restrict the Movement of SICK People' Facebook Meme
On April 28 2020, amid ongoing coverage of astroturfed anti-lockdown protests , a Facebook post claimed that quarantine was intended to "restrict the movement of sick people" ( archived here ): White text against a red and blue background read: QUARANTINE IS WHEN YOU RESTRICT THE MOVEMENT OF SICK...
Read more →Can Ultraviolet Light Be Injected Into the Body to Fight COVID-19?
As attention swirled around " sarcastic " remarks concerning the use of household disinfectants to treat COVID-19, some social media users attempted to gin up more support for United States President Donald Trump by fixating on another theory he shared during a heavily-criticized appearance on...
Read more →'Meeting Between Breadfruit' Facebook Meme
As the COVID-19 pandemic wore on in April 2020, a "Meeting Between Breadfruit" Facebook status update meme began recirculating; iterations of the meme were nearly identical: My name is [name], I think many people know me, no matter when our paths have crossed. Maybe some like me, and others don't,...
Read more →'Barack 6, Hussein 7, Obama 5, Covid=19'
As criticism rolled in against far-right protesters demanding their "freedom" to potentially help spread COVID-19, some social media users were apparently taken in by digital manipulation. Readers mocking the "grassroots" protests, which have actually been promoted and abetted on social media by...
Read more →Is the Georgia Governor's Mansion Closed Due to COVID-19, Despite Its Governor 'Opening' the State for Business?
As Georgia Gov. Brian Kemp (R) made the controversial decision to "reopen" the state in the throes of the COVID-19 pandemic, a Facebook post shared in late April 2020 urged readers to contact the governor's mansion to request a tour -- which were ostensibly canceled until further notice over...
Read more →