Truth or Fiction?
Menu

Truth or Fiction?

'Saturn as Captured from a Backyard Telescope'

Kim LaCapria
Kim LaCapria is a New York-based Content Manager, fact checker, and folklore enthusiast. She began debunking viral urban legends full-time in 2009, and in 2014 became the first editorial employee of Snopes.com, authoring thousands of political and viral fact checks. For several years, she worked to modernize the site and broaden its profile and scope. Those efforts came to fruition in 2016, leading to acclaim and global acknowledgement of the necessity for fact-checking and its role in slowing mis-and-disinformation on social media. Kim joined TruthOrFiction.com in December 2018. After work, she enjoys air hockey, water parks, jjimjilbangs, and internet culture.

On May 28 2022, a Facebook user shared an image captioned, "Saturn as seen from a backyard telescope" to the large public group "Physics and Astronomy."

Commenters on the post seemed to believe the sharer captured the image personally, responding:

Fact Check

Claim: Facebook post depicts "Saturn as captured from a backyard telescope."

Description: A circulating Facebook post of 'Saturn as captured from a backyard telescope' gave the impression that the image shown was a single-shot photograph. It was scheduled and shared on multiple platforms and it was originally attributed to u/danborja on Reddit.

Rating: Decontextualized

Rating Explanation: The image was originally shared to Reddit on April 30 2022 by u/danborja. As detailed by u/danborja, the image is a composite, made from stacked and sharpened images and enhanced using various programs; 'background stars from the Flaming Star Nebula' were also edited into the composition. Although it was captured using a telescope, the image was significantly processed and not simply a single shot viewed from a backyard telescope.

"What wonderful detail you were able to pick up. First time I saw Saturn in my telescope was breathtaking as well even though my image wasn't as beautiful as yours"

"Doesn't take a very flash telescope to see Saturn with your own eye, and the first time you do, well words can't describe it. Nice picture."

"What telescope , this is a fantastic image"

In response to the third comment, the sharer explained they hadn't taken the photograph themselves:

"I haven't clicked this photo sir..I found it on the internet and shared here.."

An initial reverse image search was unproductive. TinEye.com returned the following error message:

Whoops, we are sorry.

Your image is too simple to find matches. TinEye requires a basic level of visual detail to successfully identify matches. Please upload a more detailed image.

Google Lens didn't return many results, primarily links to Twitter timelines -- not tweets. One match was a May 8 2022 post by the page Astro Universo, with a caption translated to English from Spanish:

Saturn photographed from Earth through a telescope

Two of the matches linked to separate May 1 2022 posts by Tumblr users. Neither post described the image in any fashion:

https://brainrotdotexe.tumblr.com/post/683051195286323200

On May 14 2022, a Twitter account tweeted the image, attributing it to photographer Daniel Borja:

https://twitter.com/MusicaY/status/1525429875414339584

A search for "Daniel Borja" and "Saturn" led to a Reddit profile for u/DanBorja. On April 30 2022, that account shared the image to r/interestingasfuck (after which it landed on r/all).

That post was titled "Saturn through my 6" telescope," and the image matched the one in the popular Facebook post:

https://www.reddit.com/r/interestingasfuck/comments/ufgws6/saturn_through_my_6_telescope/

In comments, u/danborja linked to his Instagram account. Alongside other space images, the Saturn one was featured and captured:

Equipment:
????Celestron Nexstar 6SE
???? ZWO ASI290MC
TeleVue Barlow 2x
Optolong UV/IR Cut filter

In the Reddit thread, u/danborja reiterated the equipment used, adding a bit more context about the image's processing:

Processing:

Stacked in Autostakkert
Sharpened in Registax
Added background stars from the Flaming Star Nebula, taken at 250mm
Added glow in Photohsop [sic]

In that subthread, u/CrankyPelicans asked what the image looked like "before processing." In response, u/Kid__A__ clarified how images like the viral Saturn one were created:

I do astrophotography as well- it takes 1,000's of video frames stacked to make this. Each individual frame is much blurrier [because] of atmospheric turbulence, but when averaged together the details pop out. A single frame would look much less crisp but probably still pretty rad. He also added in a background field of stars, so that wouldn't be there.

Borja (@spacebydan) also tweeted the image on April 29 2022. In the tweet, he described it as a "composite image":

https://twitter.com/spacebydan/status/1520153780997742592

A circulating Facebook post of "Saturn as captured from a backyard telescope" created the impression the image shown was a single-shot photograph. The image was originally shared to Reddit on April 30 2022 by u/danborja. In the comments, u/danborja explained that the image was stacked, sharpened, and enhanced using various programs; "background stars from the Flaming Star Nebula" were also edited in to the composition. Borja shared the image in a popular tweet, and noted that it was a composite image.